Firearms – Sentencing Reform

Posted on:

The Sentencing Council is consulting on a new guideline for some of the most commonly prosecuted firearms offences. At the moment, guidance is to be found only in case law, and this can lead to a challenging sentencing exercise.

The purpose of the guideline is to provide consistency in sentencing, and the impact assessment does not suggest that any general increase in sentences is to be expected, although in many instances the Sentencing Council was met with a weak evidence base to evaluate this one way or the other.

If consistency is achieved, you would expect some sentences to increase, and some decrease, but overall average sentence lengths to be broadly level. However, experience with some other guidelines does suggest that sentence length may creep upwards.

Overall, we would expect it to be easier to predict the likely sentence that a person might receive on a plea or after trial.

One interesting observation is concerning statutory minimum sentences for some offences:

“The Council was surprised to note that exceptional circumstances were being found in around two thirds of disguised weapons cases (section 5(1A)(a)) which appeared to run counter to the principle that in order to justify the disapplication of the five year minimum, the circumstances of the case must be truly exceptional.”

The Council, therefore, felt that:

“Setting out the principles in a guideline is likely to lead to them being more consistently applied, which in turn could lead to exceptional circumstances being found in fewer cases.”

It was also noted that recent changes to Crown Prosecution Service charging guidance for some firearms offences would in itself lead to fewer mandatory sentence cases being prosecuted.

 

Which offences will the new guideline cover?

Eight guidelines will cover the following offences in the Firearms Act 1968:

  •     Possession, purchase or acquisition of a prohibited weapon or ammunition
  •     Possession, purchase or acquisition of a firearm/ammunition/shotgun without a certificate 
  •     Possession of a firearm or ammunition by person with previous convictions prohibited from possessing a firearm or ammunition 
  •     Carrying a firearm in a public place 
  •     Possession of firearm with intent to endanger life 
  •     Possession of firearm or imitation firearm with intent to cause fear of violence
  •     Use of firearm or imitation firearm to resist arrest/possession of firearm or imitation firearm while committing a Schedule 1 offence/carrying firearm or imitation firearm with criminal 
  •     Manufacture/sell or transfer/possess for sale or transfer/purchase or acquire for sale or transfer prohibited weapon or ammunition.

The consultation runs until mid-January, so it is likely to be Summer 2020 before any new guidelines take effect, but that is not to say that some judges will not have them in mind before then.

 

How we can assist

If you need specialist advice in relation to any criminal investigation or prosecution, then please contact us on 0113 247 1477 or email us at [email protected] and let us help. We can advise on all aspects of your case.